2014/15 · Champions League / European Cup, Third qualifying round ·
2–4 ·
APOEL through on aggregate
1986/87 · Champions League / European Cup, First round ·
3–3 ·
APOEL through on away goals
1982/83 · Champions League / European Cup, First round ·
3–2 ·
HJK through on aggregate
Every knockout round the two met in, with who went through by the rules of the time; the aggregate is HJK's first. A tie still to play isn't counted, and none are shown with a home or away filter, as a tie is played at both grounds.